Meek’s Cutoff – Spiritual aspects of being lost
Meek’s Cutoff is a radical movie. Its visual openness reflects the landscape through which the three families wander, not sure where they are going. I whispered to my companion, Could this be the first time a man wouldn’t ask for directions? It’s not so awful that they are lost, although things seem quite dire. But it is that they are closed. For the moment, so are we. And therein is the metaphor.
Because we are lost and will not admit it, we refuse open up and ask for directions. What this movie does in its quiet and determined (if meandering) narrative development, is shift our focus from requiring a specific goal complete with a map, to settling into trust. What do we trust? Who do we trust? How do we come to trust?
I was never surprised that an Indian was captured to become their guide and replace the arrogant egotist who would not admit to being lost. His small-mindedness made him reluctant, hateful and condescending, unable to trust the native man who so beautifully, spiritually, and mysteriously reflected and blended into the land that spawned him. (I kept thinking the settlers’ clothes were too clean and organized for the months’ long camping ordeal they were on.) He didn’t immediately inspire the confidence to reassure us and the party of three families that everything would work out. This is not just because of the language barrier but because of the human membrane that separates us from ourselves and from our own instincts. And we hold onto our separateness so it stays that way.
But, sometimes, dignity trumps arrogance. The “Indian” (so credited) somehow felt his way through the landscape, singing to his ancestors, communicating with the divine, and trusting his instincts. He emerges as a powerful model, initially for Williams’ character who was open enough to fall into trust. By the time the movie ends, astonishingly unresolved, we too have fallen into trust without any easy answers.
The point is not whether they find water or reach their still unknown destination but that they had achieved some grace, overcome bigotry and racial profiling, learned to surrender and, against the odds, survived their own perceived separateness.
Meek’s Cutoff (2010) Review by Carol Terry
Cast: Michelle Williams, Bruce Greenwood, Will Patton, Zoe Kazan, Paul Dano, Shirley Henderson
Director: Kelly Reichardt
Running Time: 104 min.
Genre: Western
June 27th, 2011





